Your Trusted Expert Source to Buy & Sell Rare Coins

Sam Shafer Numismatics serves Fishers, the greater Indianapolis area, and beyond as a rare coin dealer with unrivaled expertise, passion for the history behind the coins, and a steadfast commitment to integrity and fair service.

Why Work With Sam Shafer?

A few of the reasons clients love working with Sam:

  • Collectors & sellers at all levels of experience are welcome. I’m just as comfortable and thorough evaluating grandpa’s pocket change as I am handling exquisite rarities.
  • A unique and wide ranging inventory with coins in most price ranges.
  • Flexibility, honesty, and sophistication from a coin dealer conveniently located on the North side of Indianapolis, serving Fishers, Carmel, and the Greater Indy area.


We are appointment-only. Appointments are available Monday - Saturday from 10am to 6pm.

Make an Appointment

After you complete the form below, Sam will be in touch with you promptly to schedule your appointment.

How would you prefer to be contacted? (Choose all that apply.)

What is your main reason for contacting us?

Sam Can Help You


Build your collection.
Are you new to coin collecting and want to start building your collection? Or are you an experienced collector looking to explore select rarities? Either way, Sam Shafer Numismatics can guide you, give you the history behind the coins you’re considering, and help you assemble a collection of choice coins.


Free appraisals, no obligations.
Do you have choice or rare coins to sell — or think you might? Sam Shafer Numismatics is an aggressive buyer offering free appraisals with no obligation to sell, so you can make a fully informed decision and know you’re getting a fair deal.


Know the story of your coins
Clients come to Sam Shafer Numismatics for more than a good price. They also come for the “cutting edge, informative, and to the point” background about the items they’re buying or selling. The depth of knowledge you’ll find here is unrivaled in the area!

Contact Sam

Connect Online

The Office

11 Municipal Dr STE 200
Fishers, IN 46038


We are appointment-only. Appointments are available Monday - Saturday from 10am to 6pm.